I have found both the book and the movie to be excellent in their portrayal of historical figures on both sides of the American Civil War conflict. I particularly love the portrayal of Colonel Joshua Lawrence Chamberlain by Jeff Daniels in the movie. He gives 2 stirring speeches, one to a group of dissenters about the decimation of his unit during a prior battle and another to the men under his command about being the “end of the line” of the union army and stating that retreat is not an option. I recognize and acknowledge that both the book and movie are pieces of historical fiction and not actual historical documents so some creative liberties have been taken. I still want to use one scene from the book and movie to share a message about not giving up and repentance.
From the Confederate side, General Robert E. Lee, played by Martin Sheen, has trouble knowing what the Union army is doing because his Calvary, led by J.E.B. Stuart is nowhere to be found and therefore unable to provide valuable information to the General. This sets up a tense meeting between General Lee and General Stuart wherein General Lee expresses his displeasure with General Stuart because of the latter’s absence and for not performing his responsibilities. After being chided by General Lee, General Stuart begins to take out his sword to surrender his commission as he has failed in his duties as a commander. General Lee hurriedly and emotionally tells General Stuart, “there is no time!” General Lee is not asking for the surrender of General Stuart’s command, but rather wants to reiterate how important he is to the Confederate army and then invites him to return to his duties and prepare for the final day of battle. This is the only significant screen or book time that General Stuart is given but I think there’s a lesson to be learned.
Often, I feel like General Stuart when I make a mistake. I think to myself, “well, that’s it. I’ve messed up too badly. I need to turn over my command and give up.” I don’t think that is the purpose of repentance but rather, we need to repent, learn from the mistake, and get back to our figurative commands. In an April 2019 General Conference address, President Nelson said:
"Too many people consider repentance as punishment—something to be avoided except in the most serious circumstances. But this feeling of being penalized is engendered by Satan. He tries to block us from looking to Jesus Christ, who stands with open arms, hoping and willing to heal, forgive, cleanse, strengthen, purify, and sanctify us."
The Lord does not ask us to give up or surrender, but rather invites us to get back up, change, and try to do a little better. I am seeking to do a little better each day. I have plenty to work on and change and feel immensely blessed to know that I am not alone. So if the next time you find yourself struggling and feeling like General Stuart, instead think of the Savior.
I’ll conclude with these words from the same address from President Nelson I referenced earlier, fitting as he makes reference to a military term: “The Lord needs men eager to repent—men with a zeal to serve and be part of the Lord’s battalion of worthy priesthood bearers.”
Perhaps instead of the Lord being like General Lee and saying, “there is no time,” He instead is inviting us to ensure that we take the time we have to repent, learn, and grow and He promises that He will be working with us throughout the process.












